I've made the random decision to blog tonight.
I mean, there's, you know, college, and homework, and a gallon of ice cream with my name on it somewhere in the freezer...but I feel like I need to get this off my chest (sometimes you have to make catharsis a priority).
I LOATHE Arthur Dimmesdale.
We've had some
"difficult to love characters" so far in AP Lit. But wow, this guy
just takes the cake (for me at least, I know Sara Swords is somewhere out there
ready to jump to the defense of her bae).
And although I had a great debate team (shout out to Phoebe, Sarah, Courtney, Olivia, and Caroline), I won't lie: my heart wasn't in it. Let's be real, nowadays if some guy got his girlfriend pregnant and then up and left her to raise the child on her own so he could resume his career as an aspiring youth minister, society would not extol him and we would all call him out on it.
Admittedly, I do
have a little sympathy for the man.
He did suffer some and was stalked by
Chillingworth (a fate I literally wouldn't wish on my worst enemy, Chillingworth was creepy af)
Also just randomly, my brother saw me blogging about TSL and insisted I put in this Asian-Dad meme:
(Sam's a bit of a wacko, but he's family, and plus this is also something I could totally see my dad saying)
Why do I hate Dimmesdale so
much? That's taken me longer to figure out. Initially I thought it was because
I hated his "woe is me, let me tell you about my secret pain", and I
do hate him for that. Plus, even if he was inflicting pain upon himself, it was not alright for him to leave Hester on her own. He is not a stand up guy.
But in all
seriousness (and it's time to be vulnerable now), I think it might be because I
see a bit of myself when I read about him. I am not an adulterous reverend in
Puritan-Hell, Massachusetts. I don't climb scaffolding at night to yell to my
fellow villagers. I don't give fantastic religious sermons. But, there was a
time in my life where maybe he and I weren't so different. I have a tendency to
trust manipulative people, and that's gotten me into serious trouble in the
past. Overwhelmingly cliché, I know, but unfortunately true.
Real talk: Sometimes
you think you know someone, and then they change, and that hurts. Sometimes you
lose best friends, sometimes you lose loves. We've talked about it a lot this
year. There's been "The Art of Losing". Newland has left Ellen. Daisy
has died. Brett and Jake have grown apart. Dimmesdale? I would say he lost Hester, but then again, he and Hester were never really together were they? He was always hiding.
I'm putting a poem
below. From my second favorite poet, Charles Bukowski:
"in this cage
some songs are born"
I write poetry,
worry, smile,
laugh
sleep
continue for a while
just
like most of us
just
like all of us;
sometimes
I want to hug all
Mankind
on earth
and
say,
god
damn all this that they’ve brought down
upon
us,
we
are brave and good
even
though we are selfish
and
kill each other and
kill
ourselves,
we
are the people
born
to kill and die and weep in dark rooms
and
love in dark rooms,
and
wait, and
wait
and wait and wait.
we
are the people.
we
are nothing
more.
Dimmesdale...maybe he was a bit of a coward. But we all have moments of cowardice. We've all screwed up, but I believe,
despite everything, it is enough to be human, even amidst all of our chaos.
Also, a little side
thought, just found this side quote from Nathan H. :
(Was this really the
same Nathan who wrote The Scarlet Letter? Wow…what a man. And happiness is a
butterfly? Pretty bold metaphor, Nate. I like to think he was having an
existential crisis while writing the Scarlet letter and then when he popped out
this quote he was eating waffles or something…)
Anne
¿Anita? ¿Nuestra Anita está sufriendo una crisis existencial? ¡¿De veras?! No puedo imaginármelo¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡!¡!¡!;
ReplyDelete¡JA! Admites que tienes simpatía para mi ¨Bae¨ (Ay… por qué no dejamos esta palabra en el año 2014?) Me molesta que no estaba en clase para defender “mi hombre”. En el fondo, yo se que la razón para mis emociones Dimmesdalianos es que nos reflejamos, esto ministre protestante y yo.
Todo el mundo... somos cobardes, ¿no?
Pues, existen las personas fuertes, los Hester Prynnes del mundo. Ellos son las personas que no quiero gustarme, debido a su valor...valor que a veces no es tan fuerte en mi carácter. Quiero ser como Hester sinceramente, pero mi corazón es(tá?) unido… atado a Dimmesdale.
Quizás la clase está llena de personas honorables, honestas, las que reconocen sus cargas, sus pecados…. Quizás soy pesimista, espero que todo el mundo sea tan despreciable como Dimmesdale y yo… Por eso me enoja con los Hesters del mundo. Cuando leía este libro, no estaba de acuerdo con las acciones de Dimmesdale, pero no puedo condenar a él, porque no estoy en posición de juzgar. En el fondo, yo sé que oculto mis problemas, incluso en detrimento de otros. No soy de carácter mejor que Dimmesdale.
¡A ver! No entiendo mis palabras propias. Hasta mañana, Anita (y posiblemente Abita, si estás leyendo esto. Es muy posible que estás preparando furiosamente para nuestra discusión en la clase de español de la mañana)
smh.... putting my pimp blog to shame
ReplyDeleteSwords, once again I feel guilty that I do not know Spanish. I guess this is how I relate to Dimmesdale, too, as my inability to speak Spanish is a constant guilt and I have yet to do anything about it. Thanks, Anne, for reminding us that Dimmesdale is an Everyman.
ReplyDelete